Jerry Dowlen on...
The Catcher in the Rye and Billy Liar: Transatlantic Twins?
The Catcher in the Rye
(1951) and Billy Liar (1959) are
famous novels of male adolescence that established their respective authors
J.D. Salinger and Keith Waterhouse as prominent names in 1950s literature. J.D. Salinger (1919 – 2010) came from New York and became a
recluse for the second half of his life. The
Catcher in the Rye rapidly propelled him to the top of the literary ladder,
but after that he chose to stall his career, with the result that he published
very little else in his lifetime.
By contrast, Keith Waterhouse (1929 – 2009) was published
prolifically throughout his life. Born near Leeds, he hit the jackpot in his
early writing career when his second published novel Billy Liar became a big seller and was adapted for theatre and
film. He continued afterwards to write a stream of novels: he wrote newspaper
columns too, and several works for television.
Can I make an argument that J.D. Salinger and Keith
Waterhouse were Transatlantic twins? Both men had huge early success as novelists,
and with a very similar type of story.
Ah, but perhaps I should be arguing that the novels
themselves – The Catcher in the Rye
and Billy Liar – are the
Transatlantic twins? Both the novels have as their central character a crazy
mixed up kid: one is a teenager who has flunked out of college; the other is a
little older and is just starting his first job, but he is still, recognisably,
a young man with what would nowadays be described as “issues”. In each novel, the entire narrative action
takes place during a very short and compressed period of time.
Hang on: did I say “crazy mixed up kid”? Maybe that is a
fair way to describe Holden Caulfield, pupil (soon to be ex-pupil) of Pencey Prep;
and Billy Fisher, undertaker’s clerk at the firm of Shadrack & Duxbury. But
the reason, of course, for the huge popularity and success of the novels Catcher in the Rye and Billy Fisher was that thousands of young
male readers readily identified with the lead characters. Through their actions
and their expressions, variously encompassing anger, frustration, rebellion and
retreat into fantasy, Holden Caulfield and Billy Fisher were perceived by youthful
male readers as being reassuringly normal. Bored with school and bored with
work? Rowing with parents? Difficulties with girls? Here were two fictional
characters that seemed to be engagingly real because of their adolescence being
filled with conflict, confusion and embarrassing scrapes.
So maybe my argument is actually that Holden Caulfield and
Billy Fisher are the Transatlantic twins? Naturally enough they differ in their
use of respective American and English slang. Holden Caulfield finds numerous
things to be “crumby” and numerous people to be “phony”. Billy uses adjectives
like “fizzing”, “flaming” and “frigging”. But in many respects the two are like
peas in a pod. They instinctively tell lies: often pointless lies, blurted out
in the spur of the moment. They both mess up when entrusted with responsibility
to look after important equipment: Holden absent-mindedly leaves all the school
fencing team kit on the subway train; Billy fails to post the annual calendars
to the company’s clients.
Some of the similarities are more positive and endearing.
For example, both boys find solace in creative writing, for which they have a special
gift. They both can be admirably self-assured in social situations with adults:
cruising the New York club and hotel night-life. Holden secures a table at a
crowded floor-show where he chats to some older girls and confidently dances
with them; Billy does a regular stand-up solo comedy act in front of a
demanding audience at a local pub.
The respective workplaces (the college and the undertaking
firm) engender feelings of cynicism: Holden silently scorns how the Pencey brochure
makes the school sound much more posh than it really is; Billy silently takes
the mickey out of the twee words and the trite pictures of pet dogs and cats on
the company calendar.
Girls are a key component of both stories. They give rise to
some of the most amusing or touching scenes. There are issues of male insecurity
such as bragging about past conquests (real or imaginary) and suffering the
pangs of unrequited love. There is an especially close parallel between the
incident when Holden suddenly accuses his cute and affectionate girl friend Sally
of being a “royal pain in the ass” and when Billy boils over with frustration
while trying to kiss the virginal Barbara on a park bench, and suddenly kicks
her handbag across the churchyard.
Light comedy and satire – sometimes laugh-out-loud – is the
prevailing tone of Catcher in the Rye
and Billy Liar. But a book rarely
becomes an enduring classic if it is one-dimensional only. Sure enough both
J.D. Salinger and Keith Waterhouse skilfully weave in moments of pathos and
pain that suddenly make the reader feel sober and more inquisitive. Holden and
Billy are too headstrong and impatient to imagine that parents, grandparents,
headmasters, teachers and bosses have anything relevant (“sage and shrewd”) to
tell them. But important nuggets of advice are heard from these elders. Holden,
indeed, is listening to people younger than himself when some subtle pearls of
wisdom are dropped.
A ride on a carousel and a ride on a railway train is the
closing incident in the respective books Catcher
in the Rye and Billy Liar. Each
is symbolic of a journey and a choice.
Fondness of family and home town can sometimes tame a
Previous articles by Jerry Dowlen in the Books Monthly Archives include:
The Catcher in the Rye and Billy Liar
Erle Stanley Gardner
Antony Sher: The History Man
Edmund Crispin, Crime Fiction Author
Computer Chess: The Imitation Game
P G Wodehouse
John Betjeman and Candida Lycett Green
Sherlock Holmes: The Seven Per Cent Solution
Muriel Spark & Jane Gardam
The Story of Edith Nesbit
Anthony Gilbert and Michael Gilbert
Rebels With A Cause
Inspector Winter: Gwendoline Butler's First Detective
The Carlton, The Commodore, and the Embassy - Orpington's Three Cinemas
The Bergerac Police Adventure Series
It's All In The Mind - Margery Allingham and Graham Greene
Berlin: Cold War Spy Thrillers
The Life and Centenary of Barbara Pym
D H Lawrence: The Sniggering Legacy of Lady Chatterley's Lover...
The small print: Books Monthly, now well into its eighteenth year on the web, is published on or slightly before the first day of each month by Paul Norman. You can contact me here. If you wish to submit something for publication in the magazine, let me remind you there is no payment as I don't make any money from this publication. If you want to send me something to review, contact me via email and I'll let you know where to send it.